How we benchmarked EASE.
We scored EASE and 237 ESOP schemes adopted by Indian startups on one five-category rubric. Here is the method, the result and the limits.
Ranked #1, by 0.39 points.
Real schemes scored between 2.3 and 4.45 out of 5. Most were functional but middling. EASE scored 4.84.
EASE 4.84, best real scheme 4.45, average real scheme 3.60, out of 5.
The rubric.
- Legal & compliance (25%). Companies Act 2013 and SBEB alignment: 1-year minimum vesting, promoter and independent-director exclusions with the DPIIT carve-out, an independent-valuer FMV, special resolution where required. Evergreen legal language rather than stale citations. Deference to the Articles and SHA. Real schemes average 3.48; EASE 5.0.
- Standardisation & speed (20%). A standard, modular structure that is easy to replicate. Who approves the scheme and who approves each grant: the Board approving the framework and a delegated Administrator approving grants scores best. Real schemes average 3.65; EASE 4.8.
- Clarity & usability (20%). Plain language over legalese, consistent defined terms, logical order. Length counts on its own: shorter, more digestible schemes score better regardless of legal thoroughness. Real schemes average 3.39; EASE 4.9.
- Founder flexibility (20%). Customisable vesting and exercise price, Board discretion on acceleration and exits, amendments without excessive friction, reasonable buyback terms. Real schemes average 4.08; EASE 4.5.
- Employee protection (15%). Clear good-leaver and bad-leaver treatment, a workable post-exit exercise window, clarity on tax withholding, fair treatment on M&A, no unreasonably harsh forfeiture. Real schemes average 3.34; EASE 5.0.
The most common defects.
- 47%: Hard-code tax and legal citations that go stale
- 42%: Leave out the promoter and independent-director exclusion
- 20%: Let the board set its own fair market value
- 19%: Leave unfilled placeholders in the final document
- 15%: Run past 9,000 words
How it was done.
- We scored 237 real ESOP schemes from companies on EquityList, each from scratch, against one rubric. EASE was scored the same way.
- Length doesn't predict quality: across real schemes, word count and score are uncorrelated (r = −0.06). EASE is 2,889 words, against a median of 7,134.
What to keep in mind.
- EquityList built EASE and ran this benchmark. It isn't an independent audit.
- EASE was scored on its default terms. Shorter exit windows would lower its employee-protection score.
- Defect rates come from a keyword scan of reviewers' notes, so they are likely a slight undercount.